Extradition in France
France is an active participant in the international justice system, which is reflected in its cooperation with Interpol through the use of Red Notice Extradition in France is a complex legal procedure that can lead to serious legal consequences, including criminal prosecution and long-term imprisonment. In the case of receiving an international arrest warrant is important to secure legal support as quickly as possible.
Our law firm has many years of experience in the field of extradition and is ready to offer comprehensive legal protection at all stages of the case. Our specialists will analyze the documents and circumstances of the case, assess risks and prospects, and develop an effective defense strategy taking into account international and French legislation.
What is extradition?
International extradition – is a legal procedure during which one state transfers to another a person suspected or convicted of committing a crime for criminal prosecution or execution of the imposed sentence. This practice is an important element of international cooperation in combating crime and is regulated by national laws, international treaties, and agreements.
Extradition is usually applied to:
- Suspects in committing a crime who have not yet been charged;
- Accused individuals who are on the wanted list;
- Convicts who evaded the execution of the sentence.
The procedure allows law enforcement agencies to hold offenders accountable, even if they have left the country. Extradition can be carried out under bilateral agreements, international conventions, or through a diplomatic request.
Also possible waiver of extradition – voluntary waiver by an individual of formal extradition proceedings and consent to transfer to the jurisdiction of the requesting state without the need for a court process on extradition. However, this process does not mean automatic admission of guilt – it merely eliminates the need for an extradition court. This mechanism is often used if the individual wishes to expedite the process, avoid prolonged detention, and wants to come under the jurisdiction of the requesting state more quickly.
If you are facing extradition issues, seek qualified legal support. Experienced attorneys will help you understand the intricacies of the law, develop a defense strategy, and represent your interests in court.
Requirements for Extradition in France
When considering a request for issuance, French courts and competent authorities are guided by both national regulations and international agreements.
One of the fundamental criteria for extradition is the principle of double incrimination. According to this requirement, the act for which the person is accused must be recognized as a criminal offense both in France and in the requesting jurisdiction. The court evaluates not only the legal designation of the crime but also the essence of the act: it must fall under the relevant articles of the French Criminal Code.
France, like many other states, traditionally does not extradite individuals accused of political crimes. Such crimes include acts aimed at overthrowing the regime or against the political system. If there is a risk of an unfair trial, biased prosecution, or human rights violations, extradition will be denied.
The principle of non bis in idem means that a person cannot be extradited for an act for which they have already been convicted or acquitted in France or another state. If French authorities have already issued a guilty verdict or acquitted the person for the same offense, repeated extradition for their prosecution is impossible.
In a number of extradition agreements with certain countries, it is stipulated that France has the right to refuse the extradition of its own citizens. As an alternative, such a person will be prosecuted in the territory of France.
France does not extradite individuals if there is a risk of the death penalty or inhumane treatment in the requesting state. If there are concerns that fundamental rights (prohibition of torture, right to a fair trial) are not respected in the requesting jurisdiction, French courts may refuse extradition.
For which crimes can France extradite individuals?
France can extradite individuals for most criminal offenses. The most common include:
- Serious criminal offenses: murder, terrorist activity, illegal drug trafficking, large-scale fraud, money laundering;
- Crimes of an international nature: genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity (subject to relevant international obligations);
- Corruption crimes, economic and financial offenses, if the amount of damage is significant or the case has considerable public resonance.
Within the framework of the European Arrest Warrant, a list of “serious” crimes (more than 32 categories) is provided, for which a simplified extradition procedure is possible without checking double criminality, provided that the punishment exceeds a certain threshold (for example, imprisonment of more than 3 years).
Moreover, it is also worth considering the grounds for contesting extradition in France:
- The act is not criminally punishable under French laws, or if the statute of limitations has expired in France;
- The political nature of the accusations;
- The threat of torture, inhuman treatment, the use of the death penalty, the lack of guarantees for a fair trial in the requesting country;
- The person has already been convicted or acquitted for the same crime (principle of non bis in idem);
- Improperly prepared requests, missed submission deadlines, and violations of formal requirements of international agreements may serve as grounds for refusal.
To competently protect your interests, it is necessary to understand not only international and national regulations but also the nuances of their practical application in French courts. It is recommended to consult experienced attorneys specializing in international criminal law and extradition procedures. This approach will help identify discrepancies in a timely manner and protect your rights.
How does the extradition process work in France?
Since 2004, a simplified procedure for issuing under the European Arrest Warrant (EAW) has been in effect within the EU. After the national authority of France verifies the authenticity and legitimacy of the EAW, the person can be arrested. The detainee is promptly brought before a competent court, where their identity and the grounds for further detention are reviewed.
The detained person is provided with a lawyer. In the case of an EAW, the final decision is made by the court. Executive authorities do not interfere in the process unless there are specific political-diplomatic reasons. If the court issues a ruling on extradition, the extradition proceeds very quickly, without additional approvals, which distinguishes the European Arrest Warrant from the classic procedure.
When a request comes from a state that is not a member of the European Union, more complex procedures are applied, including taking into account bilateral extradition agreements. The Ministry of Justice of France, often with the participation of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, verifies whether the request complies with international conventions, bilateral agreements, and national legislation.
If the request is deemed acceptable, the competent prosecutor or investigating judge in France makes a decision on detention. The suspected or convicted person is detained and informed of the existence of an extradition request. The case is referred to the Court of Appeal specializing in international cases.
The detainee has the right to challenge the legality of the request and point out procedural violations, refer to the risk of human rights violations, indicate the absence of elements of a crime, or the expiration of the statute of limitations.
The judge delivers an advisory opinion on whether it is possible to extradite a person to the respective state. Unlike the EAW mechanism, here the final decision on extradition is made by the Prime Minister or the Minister of Justice of France. If the government permits extradition, the execution of the extradition is carried out by French law enforcement agencies in coordination with official representatives of the requesting party.
A court ruling on the legality of extradition may be appealed or challenged through a classification complaint (depending on the instance).
Legal Framework for Extradition in France
Section 696 of the Code de procédure pénale details the procedure for reviewing an extradition request, the jurisdiction of judicial authorities, the conditions of detention of the individual, and the timeframes within which certain procedural actions must be carried out.
Article 55 of the Constitution of France affirms the priority of international agreements over national laws if the conditions of ratification are fulfilled and the other parties to the treaty also comply with it. This means that in the event of contradictions between the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure and the norms of an international treaty regulating extradition, the provisions of the latter will take precedence.
Since 2004, the European Arrest Warrant has been applied in France. This tool is designed to simplify and expedite the extradition of suspects or convicted individuals between European Union countries. The procedure has become predominantly judicial, with minimal involvement of the executive branch. The review periods have been significantly reduced, allowing for the swift transfer of wanted persons to the state that issued the warrant.
Like many other countries, France does not extradite its citizens under classic (non-EU) extradition procedures. This rule is based on the sovereign right of the state to protect its nationals and on the principle that such individuals can face French justice.
Extradition Agreements with France
France actively participates in international agreements aimed at combating crime. Therefore, the country has concluded bilateral and multilateral extradition treaties with dozens of states.
Extradition treaties make it possible to ensure the prosecution of individuals who have fled to another country after committing a crime. Such agreements define the procedure for extradition, including the conditions for submitting a request, grounds for refusal, and the process of surrender.
France has extradition agreements with the following countries:
Moreover, in all EU countries, the extradition procedure is possible based on the European Arrest Warrant.
Extradition between the USA and France
Extradition between the United States and France is governed by a bilateral treaty that defines the conditions for the surrender of individuals accused or convicted of crimes. This treaty is aimed at strengthening cooperation between the two countries in combating international crime and ensuring justice. The mutual legal assistance treaty between the countries was signed in 1996. It establishes the legal framework for the transfer of accused persons, as well as the requirements and conditions that must be met by both parties.
The act for which a person is being sought must be recognized as a criminal offense both in France and in the United States. France does not extradite individuals if they face the death penalty. In the United States, the death penalty is a legal punishment in 27 states. Therefore, the state must provide guarantees that this punishment will be replaced with life imprisonment.
Extradition applies to individuals accused or convicted of crimes punishable by imprisonment for a term of one year or more in both countries. Crimes related to terrorism, financial fraud, cybercrimes, and drug trafficking are of priority importance. Military and political crimes are not subject to extradition.
France does not extradite its citizens, even if they are accused of committing a crime on the territory of the United States. In such cases, France may take over the criminal prosecution and consider the case on its own territory.
The extradition procedure begins with the United States submitting an official request through diplomatic channels to the French authorities. Then, the French judicial system evaluates the request, checking it for compliance with French law and international obligations.
Our law firm offers comprehensive protection in extradition matters: case analysis and search for possible grounds for contestation, representation in courts and government bodies in France, preparation of arguments for appealing the request. We are ready to defend your rights and freedom at all stages of the process.
Extradition between France and Canada
The extradition agreement between France and Canada was signed on June 17, 1988, and came into force in 1989. The agreement was developed in accordance with international standards and takes into account the national legislation of both countries. It replaced an earlier treaty from 1924, introducing modern principles of legal cooperation. In addition, the extradition procedure between the countries is regulated by the European Convention on Extradition.
Both countries have signed and comply with the European Convention on Human Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. Therefore, extradition is impossible if there is a risk of human rights violations, including torture, inhuman treatment, or unfair trial.
Extradition applies to individuals accused or convicted of crimes punishable by imprisonment for a term of 1 year or more. The list of crimes is not fixed—extradition is possible for any criminal acts that fall under the laws of both countries.
France does not extradite its citizens to Canada but can undertake criminal prosecution of such individuals at the request of Canadian authorities. Canada, in turn, may also refuse to extradite its citizens based on national legislation.
How can Extradition lawyers Assist you?
If you or your loved ones are facing the threat of extradition, it is extremely important to enlist the support of qualified attorneys knowledgeable in the intricacies of international law. Incorrect actions or missing procedural deadlines can lead to undesirable consequences: arrest and extradition without the possibility of appeal, as well as violations of fundamental rights and freedoms.
Our team consists of lawyers with international experience who have repeatedly defended clients in extradition cases in France and other jurisdictions. We know all the intricacies of local legislation and current judicial practices.
We understand that each extradition case has its own specifics and requires detailed analysis. We will thoroughly examine all circumstances to offer a comprehensive solution that meets your needs.
Our main task is to defend your rights and freedoms using all legal means of protection and, if necessary, involving international mechanisms. We strive to ensure that the extradition procedure is conducted properly and the risk of an unfavorable outcome is minimized.
During the initial consultation, we will analyze your situation, assess risks and opportunities for protection. We will determine which regulatory acts and international agreements govern the case and which arguments will be most effective.
During court hearings, our lawyers will prepare the necessary motions, help gather evidence, and ensure the protection of your interests before the French court. In case of an appeal, we will file an appeal or a cassation complaint, as well as represent your interests in the European Court of Human Rights.
Contact us right now for an initial consultation and proper legal protection. Our extradition lawyers will make every effort to protect your interests and minimize possible risks.
